Archive for the ‘TV’ Category

Simon Cowell officially leaving Idol

Wednesday, January 13th, 2010

American Idol has become one of the biggest shows in Television history, launching people from obscurity to international fame in just a few short months. It could easily be argued that many of these people may never have been able to pursue their dreams if it hadn’t been for the show. Stars like Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood, Daughtry, Kris Allen and Jennifer Hudson may have never seen their dreams become reality. The biggest star of the show, however, has to be Simon Cowell.

The music mogul, who was previously best known for launching Westlife’s career, was first seen as the nasty judge on the British version of the show, “Pop Idol.” When Fox decided to bring the show to America, they knew that Cowell was a key factor in the show’s success. When Idol launched on American television, Cowell become a house hold name, the judge people loved to hate.

This week, Cowell officially announced that he would be leaving American Idol after his ninth season with the show. He will be launching his own talent show, X Factor, in America. The show has already proved popular in Britain, with Leona Lewis being its biggest success story to date.

The big question on everybody’s mind is what will happen to the show now that its star is leaving. The show has yet to see what effect the bubbly Paula Abdul’s loss will have, never mind its leading man. Although Paula was a big loss to the show, her replacement, Ellen Degenerous, is someone many people are looking forward to seeing. But with Simon Cowell gone, can the cash cow hold its already diminished audience?

I tend to think that if the X Factor import is a success, American Idol may be brought to a close. Fox, realising that the two shows can’t compete, has cleverly pushed their dates as far apart as possible. But how many talent shows does America need, or more correctly how many does it want? Only time will tell.

Marc Williams

Two Idols Winners for SA

Saturday, May 9th, 2009

Idols SAIf you haven’t heard already, the spectacularly embarrassing news from M-Net (South Africa’s leading Premium Channel) is that they have had to award the South African Idol crown to both finalists.

After what M-Net claims was an unprecedented amount of voters, (2.4 Million) a large amount of votes that were sent through before the cut off time only arrived well after the cut off time, easily 600 000 votes. Sasha Lee was crowned at the end of the finale but her victory was short lived. On Monday morning during some internal investigating the M-Net crew knew something was wrong. They called in an auditing firm, KPMG, to audit the results. It was found that Jason had in fact won by a resounding 200 000 votes.

They have now decided to give both contestants a recording contract and car, with the rest of the prizes being split equally. The news yesterday afternoon made many people angry. Many people are now arguing that Jason should be the sole winner because he is the true winner.

Let’s look at it from M-Net’s point of view. This is a huge mistake. How do they keep all the viewers, who voted 2.4 million times, happy and willing to vote again in the next competition? If they had taken it away from Sasha Lee it would have been humiliating for her, and they would be in trouble. They couldn’t ignore it either because viewers had been complaining for most of the week about not being able to send through their SMS for Jason.

Nobody seems to be taking the blame; everybody is pointing fingers at everybody else. So the really serious question is whose fault was it that such a monumental mistake could be made?

Idols South Africa: Season 5 Final Week

Wednesday, April 29th, 2009

Idols SASouth African Idols is heading into its final weeks, and after months of searching South Africa finally has its top two Idols. Jason and Sasha Lee hit the Idols stage this Sunday where a weeks worth of votes will be summed up in what M-Net will call an Idols extravaganza. But how much of an extravaganza has this season been, and has it lived up to the high expectations I put forward in my first article.

The simple answer is, no. Let me make a flat statement right here, MNET should never have run the South African Idols over the same period as American Idol. American Idol has defined reality television with almost eight full series under its belt and superstars emerging from every corner of its alumni. It’s difficult not to compare the two shows. Yes, South Africa doesn’t have as much of a budget. Nor do its people have the money to create what we know as superstars but more could be done.

In fact, the same problems plague the SA version as when it started. I rejoiced at the removal of Colin Moss, but the rejoicing was premature. I never thought anybody could be worse than Moss, I was wrong! Liezel has rather unnatural mannerisms in front of the camera, a huge surprise to me as she was nominated for best female presenter for some other show. Are our standards dropping?

But the presenter can’t be blamed for everything. The judges, as usual, are totally clueless and seem partially tone deaf at the best of times. Not only that but the men aren’t in the least bit entertaining. At least Mara has some life, and a few intelligent things to say. Gareth Cliff is beginning to come off as an old timer who won’t let go of his rebellious teenage years. Randall, who tries to be mean but ends up looking stupid, has become even worse in season five. But Dave takes the cake. The man who, supposedly, is a big shot at Song BMG, seems to have very little music knowledge and has as much entertainment value as dead grass.

Again, the judges can’t hold all the blame. Whoever is writing the shows script is completely clueless. The lines they force the presenter to read, not that she can, are frustrating at the best of times. And as for sound quality, I will never buy any Shure products because if that’s the quality they produce I would rather speak through a loud hailer.

With all that said, season five has turned out to have better quality contestants. Hopefully if MNET continues the Idols masquerade they’ll look into its problems and continue to improve. That’s all we ask.

Idols South Africa: Season 5 Kicks off

Thursday, February 5th, 2009

Idols SAIdols South Africa: Season 5 kicked off this Sunday with a spring in its step. I have always been extremely critical of the South African Idols as it’s way too hard not to compare the show to its American counter part. Although the show has enjoyed success over the years it hasn’t produced a star that not only blows viewers away but stays in the lime light. This year may be different.

Although we’re only in its first week I have to say the editing is on a whole new level. No more irritatingly long bits that are totally unnecessary the show flies by with a professional edge that has been lacking in previous seasons. The judges are all back and although Randal Abrahams still seems intent on using lame descriptions to try to be funny, the editors seem to have cut it down to a minimum. Gareth Cliff and Mara Louw continue to be the judging entertainment, and Dave Thomson says very little.

The best part of the new season has to have happened in the opening in Cape Town. Former annoyance with the title of presenter, Colin Moss, was sent off in the best possible way. He was hit by a mini buss. What makes for one of the greatest moments of South African television Moss was killed off and replaced with a better, far less irritating, Liezel van der Westhuizen.

The talent is sharp and the funnies keep coming. Cell phone’s are instruments and singing with an iPod in your ears seems to be O.K. in one auditioner’s head. Of all the seasons of South African Idols this is one I will definitely be watching. If MNET keeps this up I will be extremely impressed.

High School Musical SA wraps up

Sunday, September 28th, 2008

High School Musical SACarmen and David are the first South African Troy and Gabriella. Last night, in a jam packed theatre, the final six sang for the last time as contestants. After a couple of songs from the final six and a seemingly large amount of dancers, the bottom two finalists were dropped from the show. Danni was the first to go, followed by Lyle.

Danni was a good singer and dancer but struggled to do both at once. If she had gotten her breathing right she may have gone further. There is nothing nice I can say about Lyle, so I won’t say anything except that I was glad to see him go.

HSM SA WinnersThe final four were definitely the strongest and proved it with their final individual songs. Daniel, although talented, doesn’t look comfortable on stage and battles to hold his accent when singing. Tshepi has a strong voice but it seems too deep for the Gabriella role. Carmen has the full package with a clear voice that plays out beautifully. Although Daniel looked more like Troy David definitely has the stage presence and a stronger voice. Unfortunately he did hit a few bad notes, especially on his wining song with Carmen.

All in all, the best won in the end. Although not the most amazing show we have seen from MNET it was definitely a good attempt and a nice spin on reality talent competitions.